Solar Roof vs. Rooftop Solar Panels: Key Differences for New Construction and Reroofing
A solar roof has the solar built into the roof covering, so one product does both jobs. Rooftop panels sit on racks above a separate, finished roof. Neither one wins every time. It mostly comes down to whether you need a new roof anyway, how much you care what the roof looks like, and how simple the roof is.
Side by side
| Solar roof (roof-integrated) | Rooftop panels (rack-mounted) | |
|---|---|---|
| Roof covering | Included. The solar product is the covering | Separate. You need a roof underneath |
| Looks | In the roof plane, with matching passive panels | Modules visible above the roof |
| Usual timing | New build or full roof replacement | Any time, if the roof is in good shape |
| Who's on site | Roofers and electricians together | A solar crew on an existing roof |
| Product choice | Fewer systems. The design follows the one you pick | Lots of modules and mounting options |
| Complicated roofs | Passive panels fill what can't be active | Modules go only where they fit |
| Roof work later | Roof and solar are one system to maintain | Modules may have to come off for roof work |
| Fair cost comparison | Against a new roof plus solar | Against the solar system alone |
If you're building new
On a new building you can go either way. The case for a solar roof is that the roof design, the panel layout and the cable routes get worked out together, which matters most when the roof is something people will actually look at. The case for rooftop panels is flexibility. If the roof design is already fixed, or you want the widest choice of products, panels are the practical answer.
If you're reroofing
When the roof is coming off regardless, you're really comparing two complete packages: a new roof with panels mounted on it, or one integrated roof. When the roof isn't due, the math is different. Putting panels on the roof you already have is less work, and we'd tell you so.
How we'd go about deciding
- Find out how much life the existing roof has, or how far along the new roof design is.
- Be honest about how much the look of the roof matters to you, and to any review board.
- Get both options laid out on your actual roof, not a generic one.
- Compare whole costs: roof plus solar on one side, integrated roof on the other.
- Check what approvals and paperwork each option needs where you live.
Best for
- Projects that are buying a new roof anyway
- Owners and designers who want a uniform roof
- Simple roof planes with good sun
May not be best for
- Roofs with plenty of life left
- Projects set on a particular module brand
- Very fragmented or shaded roofs
Questions we get asked
Does a solar roof always look better?
It sits flat in the roof and uses matching panels, and plenty of people prefer that. But looks are a judgement call. Go and see finished roofs before you decide.
Which makes more electricity?
That depends on the products, how much of the roof is active, which way it faces and how much shade it gets. Compare the two designs for your roof, not the two categories.
Can I fit panels now and switch to a solar roof later?
You can, but you'd be paying for two separate things. If a new roof is likely in the next few years, compare both before you put panels on the old one.
Is every panel on a solar roof a solar panel?
No. Active panels go where generation makes sense. Passive panels finish the roof.
Technical documents
We share technical documentation project by project. Tell us what you're working on and which documents you need.
Request Technical DocumentationKeep reading
Got a roof in mind?
Discuss a ProjectPublished by ArcEdge Power.